Before we begin, I do not debate the classic status of the Back to the Future series. I love the films myself! I won’t do a full-on review here, though, because what could I possibly add to a movie that we all grew up loving that nobody else has already said?
Unfortunately, while Robert Zemeckis has made a number of great, great films, he also has some experience working in politically unsavory undertones. The entire plot of Forrest Gump has a naïve, simple man follow orders unquestionably and stumble on honor and fortune doing so… while the love of his life, Jenny Curran, finds her life slowly spiraling down the drain in her attempt to live as a “liberated woman.” My friend Martin Schneider wrote a wonderful review of Mars Needs Moms—one of the most sexist, heteronormative movies ever made—after which he actually confronted Zemeckis himself about the film.i
We all know how Back to the Future unfolds. (If you don’t, go watch it. You should anyway. I’ll wait.) The film tells a wonderfully engaging story about… Actually, I'll let Kelly Oxford explain.
Back to The Future is a cautionary tale about going back in time and discovering your Mom wants to fuck you.
— kelly oxford (@kellyoxford) September 22, 2012
For all the film’s intelligent writing, striking imagery, and incredible editing, it has one big flawii: it features two Libyan characters who don’t exactly exemplify the country’s better tendencies. Doc Brown explains that he used the Libyans' gullibility to steal plutonium from them (that they themselves had previously stolen).
|Richard L. Duran as Terrorist #1, who spends his screen time doing this.|
|Jeff O’Haco as Terrorist #2, who spends his screen time doing this.|
Yes, the Libyans exist as an almost-incidental subplot in a much larger film. Yes, the film clearly labels them as nationalists and terrorists and does not imply that all Libyans resemble them. I doubt I’d have a problem with this depiction if it existed in a vacuum.
But this film exists in a long line of films that depict every Arab character within as a provincial terrorist who shouts guttural imprecations as he wildly fires an AK-47 at anything not as brown as himself, a stereotype that predates September 11 by many years (as will become more than clear in time as this blog progresses). That such a longstanding, pernicious stereotype appears in such a venerated and otherwise-excellent film only rubs salt in the wound.
The Historical Context
Libya didn’t actually possess nuclear weapons at that point in time, and there existed no evidence of the country having an interest therein1 (although Libya and the USSR did engage in talks to build a nuclear power plant within Libya).
Nevertheless, then-President Reagan made his enmity toward Libya and its longtime ruler, Muammar Gaddafi, abundantly clear. He described Gaddafi as an international pariah and a Soviet puppet ruler. Reagan viewed Libya as a potential channel through which the Soviets could attack America and heat up the Cold War. Probably motivated by his virulent anti-Jewish sentiment, Gaddafi continued to aid revolutionaries in Palestine to combat what he called the “Zionist enemy,” as well as revolutionaries in El Salvador and Nicaragua.2 In response to Gaddafi’s inimical decisions, Reagan implemented a series of sanctions, including the 1982 oil embargo.
This little history lesson has a point: at this point in time, America considered Libya among its most threatening enemies. As America has a history of doing with its enemies, it then comes as no surprise to see Libya vilified in film. Even so, it remains important not to conflate an insane, authoritarian, evil ruler like Gaddafi with his people, whom he oppressed himself directly. Back to the Future made only perfunctory attempts—if it attempted at all—to do so.
|At least the film doesn’t show Gaddafi directly… unlike Reagan.|
I love Back to the Future. But even more so than in the things we hate, we must remain cognizant of negative images and undertones in the things we love, the films and media that actually influence us and change our worldviews as we watch (especially those as widely seen as this film). So as much as you and I love Back to the Future, it remains important not to take its depiction of Libyans seriously.
|In fact, I really wouldn’t recommend taking anything about this movie seriously.|
i I know for a fact that Marty admires Zemeckis and didn’t actually want to do that, but telling off one’s heroes comes with the film criticism territory!
ii Well, two flaws, really. The soundtrack features Huey Lewis & the News’ “The Power of Love,” a particularly annoying song from the cottage cheese of rock music.
1 Shaheen 91-92
2 Bruce St. John 121-124
Books I Cited
- Bruce St. John, Ronald. Libya and the United States: Two Centuries of Strife. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania, 2002. Print.
- Shaheen, Jack G. Reel Bad Arabs: How Hollywood Vilifies a People. Northampton, MA: Olive Branch, 2009.